Hi Dhillan,
I don't see any problem with parents of different religion. I am a punjabi and have lots of friends that are hindu/ muslims/ or christian. If all of us stood together in a line, no one can tell which religion each one of us belong to.
Do you see yourself any different from Jennifer without bringing the religion in? You should not judging people by their background, especially not making remarks like "shocked". What is it that you are shocked by? I hope that you are not a stereotype and outrageously appalling.