Discuss:Book!Edward or Movie!Edward? - Page 2

book edward wtht a doubt...i dint like rob until i read twilight..n thts onli cz he plyed edward...tho i love him now..it wud always be edward fr me...i love edward,,of the book...hes mre concerned...hes mre caring...n hes stronger thn whts shown in the movie...the new moon fyt scene..mde me upset..cz edward was shwn so weak thr....i dnt wnt tht happening agn

i watched the movie twilight 1st and then i read the book
i read the book only because i liked robert pattinson.
but i think i like the book edward better

Nice discussion

ummm..book edward all d way......even tho rob patz is very gud..bt obv no one cn beat d buk....so buk edward....

Definitely book Edward. I read the books first and my imagination of Edward was totally different. Though I have to say Robert's smile is a lot closer to Edward's. Books are almost always better than movies. The movies were really disappointing me.

me actually confused abt which edward i like better coz to think of it, i m a jake fan so i m kind of indifferent towards edward meaning that i neither like noe hate him. but after a lil thot i think i m kind of ok with both. ed is obviously a good character n rob definitely did a great job by bringing him to life.